Correction, October 2026: we removed or corrected claims and figures on this page that our sources did not support. How we handle corrections
Honey vs Molasses
Honey and molasses are two of the oldest sweeteners in human history, but they come from entirely different sources and offer distinct nutritional profiles. While honey is produced by bees from flower nectar, molasses is a byproduct of sugar refining — the thick, dark syrup left behind when sugar cane or sugar beet juice is boiled to crystallize sugar. Here is a comparison covering nutrition, glycemic index, baking conversions, types of molasses, flavor, and which sweetener works best for your recipe.
Last updated:
Honey and molasses are both mostly sugar but differ in minerals and flavor. Blackstrap molasses has 20% DV iron, 8% DV calcium, and 12% DV magnesium per tablespoon; honey has only trace minerals. For baking, they can be swapped at a roughly 1:1 ratio since both are liquid, but molasses has a much more robust, bitter flavor compared to honey. On glycemic index, honey averages 61 across 17 honeys in the 2008 international GI tables; molasses has no published GI.

At a Glance
Honey
- 64 calories per tablespoon (liquid)
- Glycemic index: 61 on average (published honeys 32–87)
- Contains enzymes and small amounts of polyphenols
- 200+ varieties from mild acacia to bold buckwheat honey
- Sweeter and milder than molasses
Molasses
- 58 calories per tablespoon (blackstrap)
- Glycemic index: none published
- More iron, calcium, magnesium, potassium per tbsp
- Robust, bitter flavor; essential in gingerbread
- Vegan-friendly; byproduct of sugar refining

Nutritional Comparison: Honey vs Molasses
The nutritional differences between honey and molasses are striking, particularly when it comes to minerals. A tablespoon of blackstrap molasses contains approximately 58 calories and 14.9 grams of carbohydrates, while a tablespoon of honey has about 64 calories and 17.3 grams of carbohydrates. While the calorie difference is modest, the mineral content is where molasses truly shines — blackstrap molasses is one of the most mineral-dense sweeteners available.
Blackstrap molasses provides an exceptional 20% of the daily value of iron per tablespoon, along with 8% DV of calcium, 12% DV of magnesium, 8% DV of potassium, and 18% DV of manganese. These minerals are concentrated through the sugar refining process — each successive boiling removes more sugar crystals while leaving the minerals behind in the liquid.
Raw honey, by contrast, is not a significant source of minerals but contains a broader range of minor compounds, each in small amounts: enzymes (glucose oxidase, diastase, invertase), amino acids, trace vitamins, and polyphenols such as flavonoids and phenolic acids. Molasses contains polyphenols of its own but no enzymes, because it is boiled.
| Nutrient | Honey (1 tbsp) | Molasses (1 tbsp) |
|---|---|---|
| Calories | 64 | 58 (blackstrap) |
| Total Carbs | 17.3 g | 14.9 g |
| Sugars | 17.2 g | 11.1 g |
| Iron | 0.1 mg (1% DV) | 3.6 mg (20% DV) |
| Calcium | 1 mg (0% DV) | 41 mg (8% DV) |
| Magnesium | 0.4 mg (0% DV) | 48 mg (12% DV) |
| Potassium | 11 mg | 293 mg (8% DV) |
| Manganese | 0.01 mg | 0.5 mg (18% DV) |
| Glycemic Index | 61 avg (32–87) | Not published |
| Enzymes | Diastase, invertase, glucose oxidase | None |
| Polyphenols | Flavonoids, phenolic acids (small amounts) | Polyphenols |
| Protein | 0.1 g | 0 g |
Values are approximate. Honey values based on USDA FoodData Central for generic honey. Molasses values based on USDA data for blackstrap molasses. Light and dark molasses have lower mineral content and higher sugar content than blackstrap.
Glycemic Index: Honey vs Molasses
Molasses has no entry in the 2002 or 2008 international GI tables, and we found no peer-reviewed measurement of molasses in people, so this page gives no GI for it. The nearest listed product is golden syrup, a cane-sugar syrup, which measured 63 in the 2008 tables (Atkinson et al. 2008).
Honey's GI averages 61 across 17 honeys in the 2008 tables, with individual honeys from 35 to 87, against 65 for table sugar. The lowest published honey value is 32, for one Romanian acacia honey (Foster-Powell et al. 2002). The US honeys tested in people measured above table sugar: clover honey 69, buckwheat honey 73 and tupelo honey 74 in a 2006 study of 12 adults (Ischayek & Kern 2006).
Molasses also contains less sugar per tablespoon (11.1 grams for blackstrap) than honey (17.2 grams), but without a published GI its glycemic load cannot be calculated. Both raise blood sugar and both count as carbohydrate; neither is a low-glycemic sweetener. If you have diabetes, count either toward your carbohydrate total and talk to your care team.
Glycemic Index Comparison Chart
Sources: acacia (Romanian locust honey), Foster-Powell et al. 2002; golden syrup, 17-honey average and white sugar (sucrose mean), Atkinson et al. 2008; clover and tupelo, Ischayek & Kern 2006. Molasses has no bar because it has no published GI.
Types of Molasses: Light, Dark, and Blackstrap
Molasses is produced during the sugar refining process, and each successive boiling of sugar cane juice creates a different grade. Understanding these grades is essential because they vary dramatically in flavor, sweetness, and nutritional content.
Light Molasses
First boiling
- -Mildest, sweetest flavor
- -Lightest color (golden brown)
- -Lowest mineral content
- -Best for pancakes, general baking
Dark Molasses
Second boiling
- -Deeper, more complex flavor
- -Darker color (deep brown)
- -Moderate mineral content
- -Classic for gingerbread, baked beans
Blackstrap Molasses
Third boiling
- -Most bitter, least sweet
- -Very dark (nearly black)
- -Highest mineral content
- -Used in BBQ sauces and baked beans
Sulfured vs Unsulfured Molasses
Unsulfured molasses is made from mature sugar cane that does not need sulfur dioxide as a preservative during processing. It has a cleaner, purer flavor and is the preferred choice for cooking and baking. Sulfured molasses is treated with sulfur dioxide during processing, typically because the sugar cane was harvested young. It can have a slightly chemical aftertaste and is less common today. When shopping, look for "unsulfured" on the label for the best flavor.

Honey to Molasses Conversion Chart
Swapping between honey and molasses is simpler than substituting either for dry sugar because both are liquid sweeteners with similar viscosity. A 1:1 volume substitution generally works, though you should expect significant flavor differences. The key consideration is not the ratio but the flavor intensity: molasses (especially dark and blackstrap) has a much more assertive, bitter flavor than honey's gentle sweetness. Light molasses is the closest substitute for honey in terms of flavor mildness.
| Substitution | Original Amount | Substitute Amount | Recipe Adjustments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honey to molasses | 1 cup honey | 1 cup molasses | Use light or dark molasses for closest sweetness. Expect a stronger, more bitter flavor. No liquid adjustments needed (both are liquid). |
| Molasses to honey | 1 cup molasses | 1 cup honey | Honey is sweeter and milder; reduce other sugars slightly if present. Expect lighter color and gentler flavor. |
| White sugar to molasses | 1 cup sugar | 1 1/3 cups molasses | Reduce other liquids by 5 tbsp. Add 1/2 tsp baking soda per cup of molasses. Lower oven temp by 25°F. |
| White sugar to honey | 1 cup sugar | 1/2 to 2/3 cup honey | Reduce other liquids by 1/4 cup. Lower oven temp by 25°F. Add 1/4 tsp baking soda. |
Quick Ratio: Honey to Molasses
1 cup : 1 cup
1 cup honey = 1 cup molasses. Expect a stronger, more robust flavor. Use light molasses for mildest taste.
Quick Ratio: Molasses to Honey
1 cup : 1 cup
1 cup molasses = 1 cup honey. Result will be sweeter and milder. Great for lightening heavy molasses recipes.
Flavor and Color Comparison
Molasses and honey offer fundamentally different flavor experiences. Molasses has a deep, robust flavor with notes of caramel, toffee, and slight bitterness — especially in dark and blackstrap varieties. The flavor intensifies with each boiling stage. Blackstrap molasses is distinctly bitter and almost savory, with an intensity that divides opinions. This bold flavor makes molasses irreplaceable in classic dishes like gingerbread cookies, Boston baked beans, brown bread, BBQ sauces, and shoofly pie.
Honey, by contrast, offers extraordinary flavor variety across its 200+ types. Mild varieties like acacia and orange blossom are delicate, floral, and gently sweet. Medium varieties like clover and wildflower offer warm, balanced sweetness. Bold varieties like buckwheat, chestnut, and manuka deliver deep, malty, almost earthy flavors that can approach the intensity of dark molasses. This diversity means you can select a honey to complement virtually any dish.
In terms of color, molasses ranges from golden-amber (light) to nearly black (blackstrap). Honey similarly ranges from water-white (acacia) to very dark brown (buckwheat). Darker varieties of both sweeteners tend to have stronger flavors. In baking, molasses produces darker baked goods than most honeys. The characteristic dark color of molasses cookies, gingerbread, and pumpernickel bread comes specifically from molasses.
Best Uses for Honey
- Tea, beverages, and cold applications
- Glazes, dressings, and marinades
- Moist cakes, chewy cookies, and honey bread
- Cheese boards and charcuterie pairing
- Drizzling on yogurt, toast, and fruit
Best Uses for Molasses
- Gingerbread, gingersnaps, and spice cakes
- BBQ sauces and meat glazes
- Baked beans, brown bread, and pumpernickel
- Rum and dark beer brewing
- Shoofly pie and molasses cookies
Flavor pairing tip: Buckwheat honey is the closest honey variety to dark molasses in flavor profile — both share deep, malty, almost earthy notes. If you want to gradually transition from molasses to honey in a recipe, start with buckwheat honey, which provides similar depth without the bitterness.
Health Claims: Honey vs Molasses
Neither sweetener is a health food: both are mostly sugar and count toward added-sugar limits. For honey, the human evidence is narrow. A 2018 Cochrane review of 6 trials in 899 children found that honey probably reduces cough frequency more than no treatment or placebo (Oduwole 2018). Never give honey to a child under 12 months because of the risk of infant botulism.
Blackstrap molasses is the bigger source of minerals: 3.6 mg of iron (20% of the daily value), 8% DV calcium, 12% DV magnesium and 293 mg of potassium per tablespoon, from USDA FoodData Central. Those are nutrition-label numbers; they are not evidence that molasses treats or prevents any condition.
What Each Adds Beyond Sugar
Honey
- +200+ varieties, from mild to bold flavor
- +Enzymes and polyphenols in small amounts
- +Sweeter and milder than molasses
Molasses
- +Iron: 20% DV per tbsp (blackstrap)
- +Calcium (8% DV) and magnesium (12% DV)
- +Potassium: 293 mg per tbsp
- +Lower sugar per tablespoon than honey
- +Vegan

Which Should You Choose?
Honey and molasses each have clear strengths, and the best choice depends on your priorities and the specific application.
Choose honey when you want a versatile sweetener with a wide flavor range. Honey works in everything from tea and toast to baking and marinades. Its 200+ flavor varieties let you match the sweetener to the dish — mild acacia for delicate applications, robust buckwheat for bold recipes.
Choose molasses when you need its distinctive flavor or mineral content. Molasses is irreplaceable in gingerbread, BBQ sauces, baked beans, and other recipes where its robust, bittersweet character defines the dish. Blackstrap molasses carries the most minerals of the two. If you are vegan and looking for a honey substitute, light molasses offers the closest sweetness level.
The bottom line: these two sweeteners complement each other rather than compete. Keep honey as your everyday sweetener for its versatility and flavor range. Keep molasses for specific recipes that demand its bold flavor. Both are added sugars, and the American Heart Association's recommendation to limit added sugars to 25-36 grams per day applies to both equally.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is molasses healthier than honey?
Neither is a health food: both are mostly sugar and count as added sugar. Blackstrap molasses has more minerals per tablespoon: iron (20% DV), calcium (8% DV), magnesium (12% DV) and potassium, where honey has only trace amounts. Choose by flavor and recipe.
Can I substitute honey for molasses in recipes?
Yes, you can swap honey and molasses at a 1:1 ratio since both are liquid sweeteners. However, the flavor will change significantly. Honey is sweeter and milder, while molasses (especially dark or blackstrap) is more robust and bitter. For gingerbread or BBQ sauce, the molasses flavor is often essential to the dish. Light molasses is the closest match to honey in sweetness.
What is the difference between light, dark, and blackstrap molasses?
Light molasses comes from the first boiling of sugar cane juice and is the mildest and sweetest. Dark molasses comes from the second boiling and has a deeper, more complex flavor. Blackstrap molasses comes from the third boiling and is the most bitter but also the most mineral-rich, containing significant iron, calcium, magnesium, and potassium. Each successive boiling concentrates the minerals while reducing the sugar content.
Is honey or molasses better for diabetics?
Neither. Both are added sugar, both raise blood sugar, and both count toward your carbohydrate total. Molasses has no published GI. Honey averages 61 across 17 honeys in the 2008 international GI tables (table sugar 65); US clover honey (69) and buckwheat honey (73) measured above sugar, and the lowest published honey value is one Romanian acacia honey at 32. Blackstrap has less sugar per tablespoon (11.1g vs 17.2g). If you have diabetes, count either as carbohydrate and talk to your care team before changing your diet.
Does molasses taste like honey?
No, they taste very different. Molasses has a deep, robust, slightly bitter flavor with notes of caramel, coffee, and sometimes smokiness — especially in dark and blackstrap varieties. Honey ranges from mild and floral (acacia, clover) to bold and malty (buckwheat, chestnut). Light molasses is the closest to honey in terms of sweetness, but the overall flavor profiles are distinct.
Can vegans eat molasses instead of honey?
Yes. Molasses is a plant-based product made from sugar cane or sugar beet juice during the sugar refining process, making it suitable for vegans. Honey is produced by bees and is not considered vegan. Molasses is one of the most popular vegan alternatives to honey; blackstrap also has more iron and calcium per tablespoon than honey.
Edited by Sam French · Raw Honey Guide Editorial Team
Source reviewed against primary literature and official guidance where available. Health content is educational, not medical advice, and does not replace a licensed clinician.
Get the Honey Buyer's Cheat Sheet (free PDF)
16 varieties on one page — color, flavor, best use and what a fair price looks like — from the 304 honeys we track.
Related Guides
Honey vs Brown Sugar
Nutrition, baking, and GI compared.
Read GuideHoney vs Sugar
Compare calories, nutrients, and GI.
Read GuideHoney Nutrition Facts
USDA reference values and label-reading context.
Read GuideRelated Articles
Honey vs Molasses: Flavor, Cooking Uses, and How to Substitute
Honey vs molasses for cooking: flavor, color, moisture, and 1:1 substitution notes. When molasses wins in baking and when honey is the better pantry pick.
Read ArticleDark Honey vs Light Honey: What the Color Really Means
Is dark honey healthier than light honey? What honey color tells you about lab antioxidant scores, minerals and flavor, and which type suits which use.
Read ArticleHoney vs Date Syrup: Nutrition, Taste, and Which to Choose
Honey vs date syrup for cooking: flavor, texture, vegan pantry use, and substitution ratios. When date syrup fits baking and when honey is the better match.
Read ArticleBrowse honey varieties
Browse All Honeys