Raw Honey Guide

Correction, October 2026: we removed or corrected claims and figures on this page that our sources did not support. How we handle corrections

Buckwheat Honey vs Clover Honey

A detailed comparison to help you choose the right honey for your needs.

Buckwheat Honey vs Clover Honey — honey comparison

Quick Answer

Buckwheat and clover honey are polar opposites in flavor and appearance. Buckwheat is dark, bold and malty, and it is the honey used in a 2007 children's cough trial. Clover is light, mild and universally pleasant. Choose buckwheat for robust flavor, clover for everyday sweetening and delicate recipes.

Share:XPinterestFacebookWhatsApp

At a Glance

Honey A

Buckwheat Honey

Color
Very dark brown to black
Flavor

Bold, malty, molasses-like

Best For

Robust cooking, strong cheeses, dark breads

Price

$10-$20 per jar

Origin

United States, Canada, France

VS
Honey B

Clover Honey

Color
Light golden to pale amber
Flavor

Mild, clean, subtly floral

Best For

Everyday sweetening, baking, tea

Price

$6-$15 per jar

Origin

United States, Canada, New Zealand

Head-to-Head

Very dark brown to black
Color
Light golden to pale amber
Bold, malty, molasses-like
Flavor
Mild, clean, subtly floral
Robust cooking, strong cheeses, dark breads
Best For
Everyday sweetening, baking, tea
$10-$20 per jar
Price
$6-$15 per jar
United States, Canada, France
Origin
United States, Canada, New Zealand

Flavor Comparison

Key Takeaway

These two honeys could not be more different.

Buckwheat honey is intensely dark, often nearly black, with a bold flavor that hits you immediately. Expect rich malty notes reminiscent of dark molasses, toffee, and brown sugar with an almost savory depth. It lingers on the palate and polarizes tasters, with people typically loving or disliking it on first try. There is no neutral reaction to buckwheat honey. Clover honey occupies the opposite end: light golden, mildly sweet, and gently floral. It is the honey equivalent of a comfortable sweater, familiar and pleasant without demanding attention. Where buckwheat dominates any dish it touches, clover blends in harmoniously. This contrast makes them suitable for entirely different culinary applications.

Nutrition Comparison

Key Takeaway

Both have about 64 calories per tablespoon and similar sugar content.

Buckwheat honey is much higher in phenolic compounds: University of Illinois researchers (Gheldof and Engeseth, 2002) measured honeys from seven floral sources at 3.1 to 16.3 µmol Trolox equivalents per gram, with the darkest, buckwheat, highest. That is a lab measurement; it has not been shown to give a health benefit at the amounts people eat. In a 2007 pediatric trial, buckwheat honey beat no treatment for nighttime cough and was not significantly different from the common OTC ingredient dextromethorphan. Clover honey has the same calories with fewer phenolics. A 2006 US study measured their glycemic index at 73 (buckwheat) and 69 (clover), not significantly different.

Best Use Cases

Key Takeaway

Buckwheat honey's bold flavor makes it ideal where you want honey to be the star: dark bread spreads, barbecue sauces, strong marinades, gingerbread, and pairing with aged or sharp cheeses.

It is also the variety tested for nighttime cough in children over two (the Paul 2007 trial) — talk to your child's pediatrician before using it that way. Clover honey handles everything else. It sweetens tea without changing the flavor, bakes into cookies and cakes without dominating, makes light vinaigrettes and fruit dips, and works as a neutral drizzle over yogurt and cereal.

Price Comparison

Key Takeaway

Both are affordably priced.

Buckwheat honey runs $10 to $20 per jar, while clover costs $6 to $15. The small premium for buckwheat reflects its shorter harvesting season and the fact that buckwheat is less widely cultivated than clover.

Our Verdict

Keep both in your pantry for their very different strengths. Buckwheat honey adds depth to bold recipes and strong food pairings, and it is the honey with a children's cough trial behind it. Clover honey is the everyday essential for gentle sweetening, baking and any use where you want honey's sweetness without its flavor taking center stage. Together, they cover virtually every honey need.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is buckwheat honey so dark?
The dark color comes from phenolic compounds and minerals carried over from buckwheat nectar. Lab studies consistently find darker honeys measure higher in antioxidant capacity than lighter ones.
Does buckwheat honey taste like buckwheat?
Not exactly. It does not taste like buckwheat pancakes or noodles. The flavor is distinctly malty, molasses-like, and rich with toffee undertones. The buckwheat plant simply produces dark, mineral-rich nectar.
Can I mix buckwheat and clover honey?
Absolutely. Blending the two creates a medium-bodied honey with more complexity than clover alone but less intensity than straight buckwheat. This can be a good introduction for people who find buckwheat too strong on its own.
Is buckwheat honey better than clover for coughs?
Buckwheat is the one that has been tested; clover has not been compared. A 2007 Penn State trial (Paul et al., Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine) in 105 children aged 2–18, one night, found parents rated buckwheat honey better than no treatment for cough and sleep; its difference from dextromethorphan (DXM), the active ingredient in most OTC cough syrups, was not statistically significant. A 2021 BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine review of 14 studies found honey improved cough frequency and severity compared with usual care; the two placebo-controlled studies it pooled were inconclusive. Talk to your child's pediatrician before using honey for a cough. Neither honey is safe for children under 12 months.
Does buckwheat honey have significantly more antioxidants than clover?
In lab tests, yes. Gheldof and Engeseth (2002, Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry) measured honeys from seven floral sources at 3.1 to 16.3 µmol Trolox equivalents per gram, with the darkest honeys, such as buckwheat, at the top and light honeys lower. The phenolic compounds behind the dark color are what the test measures. A lab antioxidant score has not been shown to translate into a health benefit from eating honey.
Is buckwheat honey lower in glycemic index than clover?
No. A 2006 study in 12 healthy adults (Ischayek and Kern, Journal of the American Dietetic Association) measured buckwheat at GI 73 and clover at 69, with tupelo at 74 and cotton at 74; the differences were not statistically significant, and GI was not related to fructose-to-glucose ratio. Treat any honey as sugar if you are managing blood glucose.

Best Honey For...

Best Honey for Baking

Thanksgiving 2026 baking: ¾ cup clover honey per cup of sugar (King Arthur Baking), about 3 tbsp les...

Honey for Coughs & Colds: What the Trials Found

What the honey and cough trials tested, which honeys they used, what they did not show, and the coug...

Best Honey for BBQ and Grilling

Fire up the grill with the perfect honey for BBQ glazes, marinades, and sauces. Learn which varietie...

More Honey Comparisons

View all

Manuka Honey vs Regular Honey

Manuka honey contains methylglyoxal (MGO) at concentrations from 83 to 1,200+ mg/kg, graded on the UMF scale. Sterile me...

Raw Honey vs Regular Honey

Raw honey is strained but not heated or finely filtered, so it keeps its pollen, enzymes and natural tendency to crystal...

Manuka Honey vs Buckwheat Honey

Both are dark, strong honeys, but buckwheat costs a third as much. Buckwheat is the honey used in a 2007 Penn State tria...

Clover Honey vs Wildflower Honey

Clover is the consistent, versatile everyday honey: mild flavor, ideal for baking and tea where honey should sweeten wit...

Related Guides

Seasonal Honey Guide

How seasons affect honey production.

Read Guide

Buckwheat Honey Guide

Lab antioxidant data, the 2007 cough trial, flavor, and buying tips.

Read Guide

How Bees Make Honey

The journey from flower to jar.

Read Guide

Related Articles

consumer guide11 min read

Types of Honey: A Complete Guide to 20+ Varieties

Explore every major type of honey — from clover and wildflower to manuka and buckwheat. Learn how floral source, color, and processing affect flavor,...

Read Article
consumer guide8 min read

Thyme Honey: Taste, Colour, Origins and Price

Thyme honey is medium amber and herbal. Five catalog jars from Greece, Spain, Cyprus and New Zealand, jar prices, Pfund colour class, and how to spot a blend.

Read Article
consumer guide6 min read

Sidr Honey Benefits: Why This Ancient Honey Commands Premium Prices

Sidr (jujube) honey: where it comes from, why Yemeni sidr is so expensive, its caramel flavor, what human studies show, and how to spot fakes.

Read Article